David Berkowitz
Michael Badalucco
Reporter John Jeffries
Spike Lee
Detective Curt Atwater
Roger Guenveur Smith
Detective Lou Petrocelli
Anthony LaPaglia
Bobby Del Fiore
Brian Tarantina
Mario
Arthur J. Nascarella
Debbie Cadabra
Darielle Gilad
Officer Cruz
Nelson Vasquez
Jimmy Breslin
Jimmy Breslin
Midnight
Michael Imperioli
Detective Timothy Dowd
Peter Maloney
Sam Carr
Christopher Wynkoop
Harvey the Black Dog
John Turturro
Anchorman (as Harold 'Jim' Jensen)
Jim Jensen
Anchorwoman
Melba Tolliver
Yankee Broadcaster (voice)
Phil Rizzuto
Woman in Car #1/Victim #1
Danielle Burgio
Woman in Car #2/Victim #2
Lisa France
Father Cadilli
Bill Raymond
Italian Woman at Murder Site
Mildred Clinton
Italian Woman at Murder Site
Emelise Aleandri
Bowler in Diner #1
Michael Sorvino
Bowler in Diner #2
Phil Campanella
Simon's Male Friend
Dan Zappin
Simon's Female Friend (as Murielle Cohen)
Murielle Arden
Simon's Female Friend
Christina Kolbe
Neighbor
Charlotte Colavin
Bed Stuy Woman Interviewed
Joie Lee
Bed Stuy Man Interviewed
Rome Neal
Bed Stuy Man Interviewed
Mark Breland
Bed Stuy Woman Interviewed
Susan Batson
Man in Riot
Evander Holyfield
Dot, Atwater's Girlfriend
Toneda Laiwan
Young Woman Shot by Son of Sam outside Apartment/Victim #4
Janet Paparazzo
Young Woman Shot by Son of Sam outisde Apartment/Victim #5
Jodi Michelle Pynn
Woman in Car/Victim #6 (as Jennifer S. Badger)
Jennifer Badger
Wounded Man/Victim #8
Damien Achilles
Woman in Car/Victim #9
Joanne Lamstein
Johnny Nasso
Gabriel Barre
Woman Victim on College Campus/Victim #7
Tara McNamee
'L.E.S. Stitches' Band Singer
John Michael Brown
'L.E.S. Stitches' Band Bassist
Damian Branica
'L.E.S. Stitches' Band Guitarist
Lorne Behrman
'L.E.S. Stitches' Band Guitarist
Curtis Gove
'L.E.S. Stitches' Band Drummer
James Baggs
Brian's Girlfriend
Rozie Bacchi
Joe T's Girlfriend
Grace DeSena
Anthony's Girlfriend
Zoe Bournelis
Patty, Man with Weird Eyes
Frank Cadilac
Guitar Store Owner
Daniel J. Courtenay
Rocco's Girlfriend
Kathryn Hud
Man Pulled from Car
Antonio Torres
Lady at Block Party
Pamela Wehner
Girl at Block Party
Dionna Colicchio
Girl at Block Party
Victoria Galasso
Girl at Block Party
Danielle Tutelian
Italian Chef
Mario Macaluso
Officer Cruz's Partner
Andrew Lasky
Detective with Decoy Dummy
Richard Paul
Crime Scene Cop
Ray Carlson
Bouncer
Alexander J. Vega
Lady in Window
Mary Jo Todaro
Lady in Window
Jacqueline Margolis
Lady in Car Window (as Iris Alten)
Iris Braydon
Lady with Dog
Valerie Mazzonelli
Arresting Detective
Hal Sherman
Young Detective Petrocelli
Nicholas Brown
(unconfirmed)
Michelle Rodriguez
Himself - 1954 World Series Announcer (voice) (uncredited) (archive footage)
Jack Brickhouse
Bouncer/CBGB (uncredited)
David Brown
Waiter (uncredited)
Tom Cassell
Himself - 1977 World Series Announcer (voice) (uncredited) (archive footage)
Howard Cosell
Protester (uncredited)
Kevin Coyle
Club Dancer (uncredited)
Jeffrey Hoffman
Himself - 1977 World Series Announcer (voice) (uncredited) (archive footage)
Keith Jackson
Protester (uncredited)
Michael Mercurio
Detective (uncredited)
Michael J. Meyers
Protestor (uncredited)
Rich Pecci
Club Dancer (uncredited)
Christian Reeve
Man in Barber Shop (uncredited)
Kevin Craig West
